| Father Stephen Barrett |
1867 |
| Father Daniel Devlin |
1867 |
| Father Joseph Coffee |
1868 |
| Father James Nolan |
1869 |
| Father Francis O'Shea |
1869 |
| Father Francis McCarthy |
1872 |
| Father Colomba McSweeney |
1872 |
| Father William. A. Nolan |
1877 |
| Father Daniel S. Walsh |
1891 |
| Father H. M. O'Neil |
1900 |
| Father Lawrence A. Carroll |
1903 |
| Father Patrick K. Collins |
1903 |
| Father J. Andrewjeski |
1904 |
| Father Michael A. Leen |
1906 |
| Father James J. O'Connell |
1922 |
| Father Dennis N. Murphy |
1923 |
| Father James L. Stewart |
1924 |
| Father Edward A. Richards |
1927 |
| Father William J. Mullen |
1933 |
| Father William D. Savage |
1933 |
| Father William J. Donnerbauer |
1942 |
| Father Ralph. W. Young |
1943 |
| Monsignor William J. Spiegel |
1946 |
| Father Thomas McCarthy |
1945 |
| Father Peter A. Kuenzig |
1946 |
| Father Michael E. Kubacky |
1948 |
| Father John J. Hugo |
1948 |
| Father John P. Fitzgerald |
1950 |
| Father Regis Ragan |
1951 |
| Father Francis T. Weaver |
1952 |
| Father Edward L. Murray |
1952 |
| Father Hubert Klaesener, M.S.C. |
1955 |
| Father John B. Corbett |
1956 |
| Father John J. Scanlon |
1957 |
| Father Charles O. Peterman |
1958 |
| Father Adelbert E. Williams |
1958 |
| Father Joseph R. Lemp |
1960 |
| Father Edward J. Busch |
1961 |
| Father Joseph M. Hoc |
1962 |
| Father Robert Davis |
1962 |
| Father Ralph V. Stack |
1964 |
| Father Robert R. Werthman |
1965 |
| Monsignor Charles A. Thomas |
1965 |
| Father Francis A. Glenn |
1965 |
| Father Robert M. Friday |
1965 |
| Father John Ayoob |
1966 |
| Rev. Hugh Gloninger |
1989 |
| Father Wm. P. Shaughnessy |
? |
| Very Rev. Harry Bielewicz |
2001 |
| Father Steve Neff |
2007 |
| Father Nicholas J. Argentieri |
2009 |
| Father Gerald J. Lutz |
2010 |
